2027 United Catholic Appeal
Across the generations, bonds of priests create blessings for the faithful
Father Stephen Giannini, left, and Father Anthony Armbruster, posing in SS. Francis and Clare of Assisi Church in Greenwood, served together from 2024-26. Father Giannini was the pastor of SS. Francis and Clare of Assisi Parish in Greenwood and St. Martin of Tours Parish in Martinsville, while Father Armbruster served as parochial vicar in the faith communities. As a newly ordained priest in 2024, Father Armbruster learned much from Father Giannini about the daily life and ministry of a parish priest. (Photo courtesy of Cantaloupe)
By Sean Gallagher
Father Anthony Armbruster spent six years in priestly formation at Saint Meinrad Seminary and School of Theology in St. Meinrad before he was ordained on June 1, 2024.
He then spent two years serving as a parochial vicar (also known as an associate pastor) of SS. Francis and Clare of Assisi Parish in Greenwood and St. Martin of Tours Parish in Martinsville.
At the end of that time, Father Armbruster reflected on his gratitude for the support he’d received both from the parishioners he served and Catholics across the archdiocese.
Their contributions to the United Catholic Appeal (UCA) paid for the priestly formation that Father Armbruster received at Saint Meinrad.
“The people who sit in these pews here in this church are the reason that we have priests,” he said while sitting in SS. Francis and Clare Church. “I am very much grateful to the people of the archdiocese for those six years.”
This help continued during his two years at the Indianapolis South Deanery faith community.
‘One of the best priests to learn under’
The parishioners there helped Father Armbruster grow into his priestly identity. It’s a task they’ve carried out with many newly ordained priests who have served there since the faith community was founded in 1993.
“They really understand the great mission that they have in forming the new priests,” said the priest, who now serves as a parochial vicar at St. Luke the Evangelist Parish in Indianapolis. “They’re more willing to support [the UCA] because they understand that their priests are the reason why they’re able to have the sacraments. Their priests are so important to them.”
That very much included Father Stephen Giannini, who served as pastor of SS. Francis and Clare from 2015-26 and St. Martin from 2020-26.
A key part of his ministry during that time was to make his own contribution to helping newly ordained priests make their priestly identity their own, something that Father Armbruster is also grateful for.
“Almost every priest in our archdiocese has told me that I had one of the best priests to learn under for my first few years,” he said. “And they were absolutely right.”
Father Giannini appreciated Father Armbruster’s “dedication to the Church and to his prayer life,” adding prayer is “an important piece for all priests, to spend time with prayer with the One who loves us and allowing that relationship to influence the relationships we have with our parishioners and with anybody we come into contact with.”
Father Giannini knew from experience that his time with a newly ordained priest would be limited, so he wanted to make the most of it.
So, in Father Armbruster’s first year at SS. Francis and Clare and St. Martin, Father Giannini had him focus on getting used to celebrating the sacraments on a regular basis. That included him celebrating the liturgies of Holy Thursday, Good Friday and the Easter Vigil on Holy Saturday at SS. Francis and Clare.
Because those liturgies are the most important in the Church’s liturgical year and are also more complex than an ordinary Sunday Mass, Father Armbruster said that this assignment from Father Giannini “frightened me quite a bit.” At the same time, he said that he “very much appreciated the trust he had in me to do that.”
Although Father Giannini aided his younger brother priest by giving him specific tasks in his ministry, he also helped him simply through the relationship they shared for two years.
‘Be simple when it comes to faith’
“It’s a lot of listening,” Father Giannini said. “It’s the time at the end of a day. It’s letting the associate pastor reveal to me what they’re concerned about, or what successes they’ve had where they were so pleased that they were able to do something. I’ll sit there and affirm them in that.
“Sometimes—and I need this for myself, too—I’ll say, ‘Well, maybe we could have done it a different way,’ which is how we all learn.”
Father Armbruster appreciated the chance to learn from Father Giannini just by watching how he lived as a priest from day to day.
“One of the lessons he taught me is how to be simple when it comes to faith,” Father Armbruster said. “It just comes down to loving the Lord and giving him more and more of ourselves every single day.”
Father Armbruster saw this simplicity in Father Giannini’s “own resolve to take on the challenges of the parish” and in “sitting with the Lord and praying, even in the empty church by himself.”
“When it comes to the heart of the priest, he is so much united to the Lord that it doesn’t have to be a very complicated thing, that it’s just simply being with the Lord and knowing that he has called you to that,” Father Armbruster added. “If nothing else, he has really encouraged me and taught me to know that this is what I’ve been called to do and to be confident in that.”
Perhaps the last lesson that Father Giannini passed on to Father Armbruster came when both priests learned that they would begin new assignments in July.
‘I will serve as long as I’m able to’
Although Father Giannini at 70 was eligible to retire from parish administration, he came to the realization in prayer that “I’ve got one more adventure in my life.”
“That’s why I’m off to St. Mary Parish in Greensburg,” he said, “to have another adventure with God and God’s people there. I’m not retiring right now because I love being a priest … .”
Father Armbruster admires the dedication to priestly life and ministry he sees in Father Giannini and hopes to emulate it in his own life.
He said that when he was ordained, “I surrendered my life to the Lord and to the archdiocese. I will serve as long as I’m able to. Even if I’m past that age of retirement, but still am able to do it, I will do it.”
The support that the faithful of the archdiocese give to retired priests through the UCA helps young priests like Father Armbruster give themselves more freely to their ministry to the Church across central and southern Indiana.
“Looking at the financial struggles that are hitting people right now in our country, I realize that I am tremendously fortunate and blessed to have the support of the United Catholic Appeal …,” he said. “I can keep serving and keep doing what the Lord has called me to do, knowing that I’m being supported in that work.”
(To learn more about a vocation to the priesthood in the Archdiocese of Indianapolis, visit HearGodsCall.com. For more information about the United Catholic Appeal, the ministries it supports, to watch a video of interviews with those in this article or to donate, go to unitedcatholicappeal.org or call the Office of Stewardship and Development at 317-236-1415.) †
Related: See stories from our special section highlighting ministries supported by United Catholic Appeal