November 6, 2026

Think of your best friend to understand the life-changing gift that two sisters share

Providence sisters Barbara Battista, center, and Jane Iannaccone, right, stand on a beautiful fall day by a statue of St. Mother Theodore Guérin on the grounds of the Sisters of Providence of Saint Mary-of-the-Woods in western Indiana.  (Submitted photo)

Providence sisters Barbara Battista, center, and Jane Iannaccone, right, stand on a beautiful fall day by a statue of St. Mother Theodore Guérin on the grounds of the Sisters of Providence of Saint Mary-of-the-Woods in western Indiana. (Submitted photo)

By John Shaughnessy

Think of your best friend.

Let your mind focus on the qualities and the stories that make you smile when you think of that person.

Now consider these two questions:

During a difficult time in your life, could you count on that friend to be there for you?

During a hard time in your friend’s life, could they count on you—even to possibly do something that your friend would never ask you to do?

That’s the kind of friendship that Providence sisters Barbara Battista and Jane Iannaccone have, a friendship so deep that one of them shared an extraordinary gift to enhance the quality of life for the other—providing a kidney for a needed transplant.

And here’s one more part of the bond they share: They both believe that God puts certain people in our lives to help us on our journey in this world.

The fact that Sister Jane and Sister Barbara approach the world from different perspectives makes their friendship even more intriguing.

‘You lean on each other’

“We’re as different as night and day,” Sister Barbara says with a laugh. “Jane is gentle, quiet, slow-moving. I mean, slow-moving. I’m just the opposite. I walk fast. I talk fast. I’m kind of loud. I have a big personality. My favorite things involve being outside, taking a hike, sitting around a campfire. That’s not Jane at all.”

Sister Jane notes, “I’m basically an introvert. She’s an extrovert. She goes into a room of people, and she’s energized. She goes around talking to everyone. I go into a room full of people, and I find a quiet corner. I find a couple of people and have conversations with them.”

And yet, they are best friends, dating back 41 years to a time when they both made the decision to consider a vocation to religious life with the Sisters of Providence in St. Mary-of-the-Woods near Terre Haute.

Sister Jane hailed from the Boston area. Sister Barbara grew up in St. Joan of Arc Parish in Indianapolis. The difference in geography was similar to the differences in their personalities, but like new high school students and new college students at this time of year, they clung to each other as they navigated an uncertain beginning.

In 1985, Sister Barbara was 28 and Sister Jane was 33 when they entered the Sisters of Providence community and met for the first time.

“First of all, to come in and ask to become a sister and be accepted into what we call formation, a program in which you get brought in—kind of like boot camp for communities—your life gets turned upside down for a while,” says Sister Barbara, who is now 69.

“You’re no longer your own individual agent. You have to make collective decisions. You want to do everything right, so you kind of lean on each other to make your way through all these changes.”

As they leaned on each other, they also learned more about each other. They were both part of families that had seven children. They also shared heritages that were part Irish and part Italian.

“We came from large families, and we just hit it off,” says Sister Jane, who is now 74. “On holidays when I couldn’t travel back to Massachusetts, she’d invite me to her family’s house. That’s how the friendship started and blossomed.”

Sister Barbara notes, “We could relate to each other’s family stories—the chaos of our big families. There was also something about her kindness and her gentleness that made me feel just right at home.”

She pauses and adds, “God put us in each other’s life for a reason—that we would be supportive of one another in this very new life.”

That bond grew tighter through the years, leading up to 2020 when Sister Barbara noticed a frightening change in her best friend—a development that threatened Sister Jane’s life.

A heartbreaking discovery, an offer of hope

“At the time, Jane was living in a suburb of Boston. She was a pastoral associate in a parish out there. She didn’t recognize that she was not well, but we did,” Sister Barbara recalls, adding that she brought Sister Jane back to Terre Haute to live with her in a house that the Sisters of Providence owned.

“Over the course of a year, she moved more slowly and had a harder time thinking clearly. I was worried. Then she got the diagnosis.”

In September of 2021, doctors determined that Sister Jane had a serious autoimmune condition that had led to kidney failure for her. She needed dialysis to continue living. Shortly afterward, she was placed on the kidney transplant list—an opportunity that often takes several years.

“I did dialysis three times a week, for 3 1/2 hours,” Sister Jane says. “When you were finished, you were exhausted. Then you had a day where you felt better before you went back to the same thing. You really didn’t have a lot of quality of life.”

Seeing that change in her best friend was heartbreaking for Sister Barbara. It also reminded her of another devastating time in her life.

“In 1983, my younger brother, Eddie, died in an accident at work,” Sister Barbara recalls. “He was taking down a set after a Kenny Rogers’ concert. He fell 30 feet from above the stage. He was only 24.

“He was on life support for five days, and then we donated his organs after we took him off life support. Afterward, my older sister and I went around promoting kidney donations. I had that memory in mind. So fast forward to 2022-23. I’m thinking, ‘If I’m well enough, I should give Jane a kidney.’ I didn’t tell her until I knew if I would qualify. I was 65 then. I didn’t know if I was too old.”

Sister Barbara wasn’t too old. She just wasn’t considered a good match for her best friend. Still, there was one more way she could help. Through an approach called “a paired donation” or “donor swap,” Sister Barbara was told that if she donated a kidney to someone else, that gift would allow Sister Jane to move up the transplant list.

Sister Barbara didn’t hesitate.

The gift of a best friend and a new one

“I had no idea Barbara was contemplating it until after she had gone through all the testing,” Sister Jane says. “They said they would take her kidney, and that would move me higher on the list. Normally if you don’t have a donor, it can be up to seven years before you can receive a kidney. It’s something I’ll be eternally grateful to her for. It’s the best gift I could ever receive.”

Sister Barbara donated one of her two kidneys during a procedure at IU Health University Hospital in Indianapolis on Nov. 10, 2023.

Thirteen months later—after 2 1/2 years on dialysis—Sister Jane received her new kidney in the same hospital on Dec. 13, 2024.

“That day had great significance for me,” Sister Jane says. “Besides kidney issues, I have bad eyesight. So, I always prayed to St. Lucy for my eyes. I received the kidney on the feast of St. Lucy.”

That life-changing moment was an early Christmas gift that year for Sister Jane and Sister Barbara. Sister Jane praises the generosity of her best friend, and Sister Barbara is just grateful she could help a friend who means so much to her.

“We talk about loving your neighbor, doing the right thing, and being kind to those in your life and the stranger on the street,” Sister Barbara says. “There’s nothing quite like that feeling of knowing that someone else is up and walking around now because you gave one of your kidneys.”

Sister Jane also received the gift of meeting the person who donated a kidney to her—Susan Denison-Backhaus, who lives in Arizona and had no previous connection to Sister Jane.

“She wrote a letter to me,” Sister Jane says. “The coordinator [of the transplant unit] asked if I wanted to receive it. I did, and I called her that night. And we’ve been in touch ever since. I wanted to know her because she gave such a life-giving gift.”

The two met in June of this year after Sister Jane nominated Denison-Backhaus for a Saint Mother Theodore Companion Award, an honor that the Sisters of Providence of Saint Mary-of-the-Woods present to people who have given service to their community. Denison-Backhaus came to Indiana to receive the award and meet Sister Jane.

“It was overwhelming to meet her, like I’d known her my whole life. We just naturally clicked,” Sister Jane says. “She’s more like Barbara. She’s an extrovert and very outgoing.”

Sister Jane laughs and adds, “I figure maybe I’ll get more extroverted, now that I have her kidney.”

Her laugh reflects the difference in her quality of life these days.

‘It’s like a miracle’

“Once I healed from the procedure, it was like a miracle,” Sister Jane says. “It gave me freedom. I wasn’t hooked up to a machine any longer. I was able to be more active. It was truly a gift from God.”

Both Sister Jane and Sister Barbara also believe that their friendship of 41 years is a gift from God.

“We’re different in our theology, our spirituality, and how we pray. And yet, what stands out is that she loves me and accepts me just the way I am,” Sister Barbara says. “It doesn’t look like we have anything in common externally. But internally, that desire to lean on Providence with our whole selves, to live a devout life, and to share the struggles and the joys of it and just be there for one another—that makes all the difference.”

As she reflects on their friendship, Sister Jane’s voice has an even softer tone.

“I think God places different people in our lives to help us on our life’s journey,” she says. “Different people are placed in our lives at different times. And that strengthens our faith and our relationship with God.

“Barbara is someone I can count on day to day. She’s always there for me. We’ve shared many joys together as well as many sorrows. When times are good, we rejoice together. And when times are difficult, we support each other. She’s a true friend.”
 

(If you have a story of a special friendship you’d like to share, contact John Shaughnessy at jshaughnessy@archindy.org.) †

Local site Links: