October 23, 2026

Ministry to those in need is at the heart of the Oldenburg Franciscan’s 175 years

A choir of Oldenburg Franciscan sisters sings during a Sept. 27 Mass at their community’s motherhouse chapel in Oldenburg. The liturgy, presided over by Archbishop Charles C. Thompson, celebrated the 175th anniversary of the community’s founding. (Photo by Sean Gallagher)

A choir of Oldenburg Franciscan sisters sings during a Sept. 27 Mass at their community’s motherhouse chapel in Oldenburg. The liturgy, presided over by Archbishop Charles C. Thompson, celebrated the 175th anniversary of the community’s founding. (Photo by Sean Gallagher)

By Sean Gallagher

OLDENBURG—Mother Theresa Hackelmeier was drawn to Oldenburg in 1851 from Vienna, where she was living as a Franciscan sister, to serve German-speaking Catholic immigrants who were starting to settle in greater numbers in southeastern Indiana.

The arrival of this one sister, who was soon joined by young women of the area who felt a call to religious life, marked the start of the Oldenburg Franciscan Sisters, who have been celebrating the 175th anniversary of their founding throughout 2026.

A high point of these celebrations took place on Sept. 27 when Archbishop Charles C. Thompson was the celebrant of an anniversary Mass in the community’s motherhouse chapel.

The day was also the anniversary of the death of Mother Theresa, who died on that date in 1860—only 33 at the time.

Singing at the Mass and in a concert that followed the liturgy was a choir of the sisters and choirs from the Oldenburg Academy of the Immaculate Conception in Oldenburg and Marian University in Indianapolis, two schools founded by the Franciscan sisters.

Before the liturgy, Franciscan Sister Maureen Irvin, the community’s leader as its congregational minister, expressed the sisters’ gratitude for Mother Theresa’s “courage, her deep trust in God and her willingness to say ‘yes’ to God’s call.”

‘A magnet to the poor’

It did not take long for Mother Theresa’s fledgling community to take flight and start ministering far beyond the confines of southeastern Indiana.

During its 175-year history, the Oldenburg Franciscans have served in parishes and schools across central and southern Indiana. Within its first decade, the sisters sent members to St. Louis, with assignments being made to other Midwestern communities soon thereafter.

Ministry in the American southwest and northern Rockies to Native Americans and others living in the region dates to as far back as the 1920s. The Oldenburg Franciscans went even farther afield later, sending sisters to China from 1939-45 and to Papua New Guinea from 1960-2011.

In all this expansion, though, the sisters have always maintained what Franciscan Sister Evelyn Lindenmeier described as a “family spirit” within the community.

Part of that has been fostered by women from multiple generations of the same family joining the community. Sister Evelyn and her twin sister, Franciscan Sister Rachel Lindenmeier, who died in 2023, discerned their vocations in part through the example of their aunt, Franciscan Sister Leona Burkhart.

“My aunt was a big part of my vocation,” said Sister Evelyn, who joined the community in 1955 from St. Roch Parish in Indianapolis. “We came every summer to visit her. There was just something about her that drew me. Every summer when I’d go home after a family visit, I’d always look at the motherhouse and say to myself, ‘Someday, I’m going to live here.’ ”

The women who joined the community over its history lived in Oldenburg in the time of their initial formation. But it did not take long for them to be “sent out on mission,” as the sisters describe, being assigned to teach in schools, assist in parishes or serve the poor in a variety of charitable ministries.

This last example actually came through in many of their ministries, as the sisters over the years became “a magnet for the poor”—a phrase Franciscan Sister Barbara Piller attributes to Daniel Elsener, president of Marian University in Indianapolis, which was begun by the Oldenburg Franciscans.

Many of the communities in which the sisters have served have been “blue collar parishes,” said Franciscan Sister Jean Marie Cleveland, who served as congregational minister from 2000-06.

While the sisters, in the spirit of St. Francis of Assisi, naturally focused on service to the poor, this ministry in turn had a positive effect on them, said Sister Barbara, who led the community as congregational minister from 2006-12.

“That helped us to become more aware of living simply, living in the same style as the people to whom we ministered,” she explained. “It kept us more honest to the simplicity that we vowed. So, we were influenced by people we ministered to. It kept us honest and true to our calling.”

The ‘sisters who would dig ditches’

The first four members of the Oldenburg Franciscan Sisters to serve as missionaries in Papua New Guinea pose in 1960 with a child who was a native of the island nation north of Australia. They are, from left, Sisters Martine Mayborg, Annata (Kate) Holohan, Noreen McLaughlin and Mary Claver Ehren. (Archive photo courtesy of the Oldenburg Franciscan Sisters)

The first four members of the Oldenburg Franciscan Sisters to serve as missionaries in Papua New Guinea pose in 1960 with a child who was a native of the island nation north of Australia. They are, from left, Sisters Martine Mayborg, Annata (Kate) Holohan, Noreen McLaughlin and Mary Claver Ehren. (Archive photo courtesy of the Oldenburg Franciscan Sisters)

The experience of serving those in need went to a different level when members of the Oldenburg Franciscans served in China from 1939-45 as the country was torn apart both by a civil war and by an invading Japanese army. In fact, Japanese authorities kept the sisters interned for two years.

The traumatic experience of ministry in China did not dampen the community’s openness to spreading the Gospel as missionaries. Capuchin Franciscan friars serving in Papua New Guinea, an island nation north of Australia, persuaded the community to send sisters there starting in 1960.

Sister Maureen explained how the natives called the missionaries the “sisters who would dig ditches.”

“They weren’t afraid to get their hands dirty,” she said. “They weren’t above hard work.”

Franciscan Sister Lorraine Geis recalled returning to Oldenburg during the summer of that year from her teaching assignment in St. Louis, where she had comfortably served for eight years.

The community was abuzz with the stories sent back to Oldenburg by the first four missionary sisters sent to Papua New Guinea.

Hearing the accounts of the hard work of the sisters but also of the fulfilment they experienced, Sister Lorraine, who grew up in St. Gabriel Parish in Connersville, felt that God was calling her to leave her comfort zone in St. Louis for the challenges of serving in Oceania. She and Franciscan Sister Naomi Frey spoke about their interest in the new missionary venture to Mother Mary Cephas Keller, the community’s superior at the time.

“By the end of the week, Sister Naomi and I were going to get our shots and our passport pictures,” recalled Sister Lorraine. “It went that fast.”

While her discernment of missionary work happened quickly, her service in Papua New Guinea wasn’t a flash in the pan. Sister Lorraine continued her missionary ministry until 2001 when she returned to the U.S.

The service of the Oldenburg Franciscans in Papua New Guinea affected the lives of people far beyond that island nation. Father James Farrell, a retired archdiocesan priest, recalled how he and his fellow students at St. Therese of the Infant Jesus (Little Flower) School in Indianapolis heard about the missionaries.

One of their own beloved teachers, Franciscan Sister Martine Mayborg, was among the first sent to Papua New Guinea.

“She went willingly to this mission with the hardships that she would face, the language difficulties and building a mission from scratch,” said Father Farrell. “That really stuck with me. You know, it really made me think, ‘What am I going to do? What contribution can I make?’ ”

That contribution has so far been 51 years of priestly life and ministry serving the Church in central and southern Indiana, something Father Farrell sees as being shaped by the witness given to him by the Franciscan sisters who taught him at Little Flower School.

“They were willing to dedicate their lives to this,” Father Farrell said. “I wanted to spend my life doing something that was meaningful and purposeful. And they were doing that every day.”

Making ‘a bigger impact’

Sending sisters to war-torn China and poverty-stricken Papua New Guinea might seem like a risky venture, but bold actions by the Oldenburg Franciscans go back to Mother Theresa herself in leaving civilized Vienna behind for the wilds of the Indiana frontier.

The community was also bold in moving what is now Marian University from Oldenburg to Indianapolis in 1937 in the middle of the Great Depression.

Elsener, Marian’s president since 2000, said that the Franciscan sisters who brought the university to Indianapolis “wanted to make a bigger impact” than they could by leaving the school in Oldenburg. They also made the move in tough economic times because they relied on the guidance given to them by God in prayer.

“They would have thought it risky to go against the prompting of the Spirit, what their experience had been and what their intellect and rational analysis taught them,” Elsener said. “I bet they thought it was more risky to sit still than to move.”

In the 89 years since Marian has been located in Indianapolis, the influence that the Franciscan Sisters who brought it there has reached around the world in the many teachers, doctors, nurses and other professionals the school has trained.

“A specific place like Marian is a dramatic example of what the Oldenburg Franciscans have done,” Elsener said. “The graduates are even more dramatic because what they do every day. They’re force multipliers of Christ.”

As Elsener prepares to transition to serving as Marian’s president emeritus after this academic year, he sees a bright future for the ongoing worldwide impact of the Oldenburg Franciscans through Marian.

“An education illumined by the light of faith and grounded in Gospel values is at its premise fundamentally different and has larger purposes,” he said. “That has caused us to grow. And that is why the sisters in 175 years have been able to have this dramatic influence on the Church, Indiana and the world.”

A ‘powerhouse of prayer’

Just as prayer played an important role in leading the Oldenburg Franciscans to Indianapolis, the members of the community who spoke with The Criterion emphasized how it is at the root of their 175 years of ministry among those in the archdiocese and in places halfway around the world.

Franciscan Sister Susan Marie Pleiss, who joined the community in 2010 and now serves on the community’s leadership team, learned during her initial formation that the motherhouse is a “powerhouse of prayer.”

She later served in Appalachia in the poverty-stricken eastern Kentucky where Catholics were a distinct minority.

“I wasn’t able to do this without the sisters behind me that were supporting me in prayer,” Sister Susan Marie said. “That’s very real to me. It’s not a theory and it’s not just lip service.”

In his homily during the Sept. 27 anniversary Mass, Archbishop Thompson praised the sisters’ “Christ-centered witness” that flows from their prayer and which he said is “indelible,” despite the many changes that have happened in the world since Mother Theresa first came to Oldenburg in 1851.

The sisters, he said, have “focused on recognizing Jesus Christ in the poor, the vulnerable, the unborn, the abused, the victims of human trafficking, the immigrant, the refugee, the sick, the elderly and the dying.

“The long history of the Franciscan sisters’ presence and ministry here has been marked by the desire to lead others to a personal encounter with Jesus, the living Word of God made flesh. He alone is Savior and Redeemer.”

Over their 175-year history, the Oldenburg Franciscan Sisters have known well that all of this ministry which Archbishop Thompson praised was only made possible through the support of many people.

Sister Maureen remembered this in her remarks before the anniversary Mass to those who had gathered for the liturgy.

“We would not be here celebrating without you and thousands like you who have prayed for us, supported us and journeyed with us,” she said. “As we begin this eucharistic celebration, may our hearts be filled with gratitude for the past, joy in the present and hope for the future.

“And may the spirit and faith of Mother Theresa Hackelmeier continue to inspire all of us here to respond generously to God’s call.” †

Local site Links: