Keys to a child’s success in grade school? New MTCA director shares tips

For Matthew Goddard, the new executive director of the archdiocese’s Mother Theodore Catholic Academies, family is a gift he shares with his wife, Nichole, and their three children, Quentin, left, Lily and Jacob. They are members of SS. Francis and Clare of Assisi Parish in Greenwood. (Submitted photo)

By John Shaughnessy

As the father of three school-aged children and as an educator for more than 20 years in Catholic schools in the archdiocese, Matthew Goddard views each new school year from three perspectives:

He sees it from a student’s viewpoint.

He considers it from a parent’s perspective.

And he knows the care and commitment that Catholic school teachers and principals bring to students and their families.

This year, he will connect his experience and perspective to his new role as the executive director of the three Catholic schools in Indianapolis that form the Mother Theodore Catholic Academies—Central Catholic, Holy Angels and St. Philip Neri.

“What called me to Mother Theodore Catholic Academies is its unwavering commitment to serving students and families with compassion and excellence,” Goddard says. “Every day, our schools provide an environment where children are known, loved, challenged and encouraged to discover the gifts God has given them. That mission inspires me, and I am excited to be part of it.

“Our schools are uniquely positioned to help students discover not only what they can achieve, but who God is calling them to become. I look forward to sharing with our families and students throughout the year. Together, by working as partners and keeping our focus on faith, learning and growth, we can help every child succeed and prepare them for a bright future filled with purpose and opportunity.”

Tapping into that experience and enthusiasm, The Criterion invited Goddard to share advice on how students in Catholic grade schools across the archdiocese can make the most of their school year—and how parents can provide a supportive path toward that goal.

Here are his recommendations:

For students: Stay curious

“Some of the most successful students I have met were not necessarily the smartest in the classroom—they were the ones who remained curious, worked hard and refused to give up.”

Treat others the way you want to be treated

“Practice kindness, respect and gratitude every day. In every school I have served, I have seen how positive relationships create stronger classrooms and stronger communities. Treating others with dignity, helping classmates, listening to teachers, and demonstrating good character often opens doors to opportunities both in school and in life.”

Get involved

“Challenge yourself to step outside your comfort zone. Get involved in activities, clubs, sports or service opportunities that help you discover your gifts and build confidence.”

Remember the basic keys to success

“Come to school ready to learn and willing to try. Ask questions when you do not understand something. Growth happens when we challenge ourselves.”

It’s OK to make mistakes

“Mistakes are not something to fear. Every accomplishment begins with learning, and learning requires effort,

risk-taking and sometimes failure. The students who grow the most are those who view setbacks as opportunities to improve rather than reasons to quit. Confidence is built one challenge at a time.”

God believes in you, believe in yourself

“Lean into the gifts and talents God has given you. Believe in yourself, because your teachers, your family and your school community believe in you. Success is not about being perfect. It is about being committed to learning, growing and becoming the person God calls you to be.”

For parents: Be a strong partner

“One lesson I have learned throughout my years in Catholic education is that student success is strongest when school and home work as true partners. To our parents and guardians, I encourage you to stay engaged in your child’s education and communicate regularly with teachers. Throughout my career, I have seen that students achieve more when parents stay engaged in their education.”

Focus on growth, not perfection

“I encourage parents to focus on growth rather than perfection. Every student learns differently and develops at their own pace. The most successful students are not always the ones who earn the highest grades. They are often the students who learn to be resilient, take responsibility for their work, seek help when needed, and continue working hard even when things become difficult.

“As educators, we see tremendous growth when families celebrate effort, character and progress alongside academic achievement.”

Remember the basic keys to your child’s success

“Create a home environment that values learning. Communicate with your child daily. Maintain routines. Connect with teachers and/or school leaders. Encourage persistence when challenges arise.”

Embrace the Catholic school mission

“Catholic schools do far more than educate—they form young people of faith, character and purpose.”

Be your child’s biggest supporter

“Most importantly, talk with your child every day. Celebrate their successes. Help them learn from challenges. Remind them that effort, perseverance and faith matter just as much as grades. Your involvement sends a powerful message that education is important and that your child has your support every step of the way.” †

The Criterion

August 7, 2026